Illustration of Prime Minister Stephen Harper by Victor Juhasz for National Observer
“Brian Mulroney was an appalling prime minister, appalling. But
if I had to pick one prime minister over the other [between Harper and
Mulroney], I would pick Mulroney.”
– Stevie Cameron, author of On the Take, the 1994 bestseller about corruption during the Mulroney years.
In the summer of 2010, U.S. President Barack Obama, British Prime
Minister David Cameron and other world leaders arrived at a swanky
resort located two hours north of Toronto to take part in the annual G8
Summit. As it turned out, the resort lies in the riding of then federal
Industry Minister Tony Clement.
At that time, no one knew that Clement had lifted $50-million from
the public purse – money originally allotted by parliament for
alleviating congestion at Canada’s borders – and spent it beautifying
his Parry Sound-Muskoka riding on things like parks, walkways, toilets
and gazebos. He would later claim the money was dispersed for the G8
Summit.
But when Auditor General Shelia Fraser investigated what happened to
the $50-million, she could find little paperwork showing how it was
decided the money be spent. Documents later unearthed through the Access
to Information Act showed Clement was encouraging mayors in his riding
to apply for this cash prior to the 2008 election – and used federal
civil servants to help dole it out. The NDP later accused Clement of
using the money as a “slush fund” to better his chances of getting
re-elected.
Still, when the $50-million scandal broke in 2011, Clement was not
dropped from cabinet or even reprimanded. Instead, Prime Minister
Stephen Harper put him in charge of the Treasury Board – the very entity
designed to oversee spending, ethics and accountability in government.
That same year, the Conservatives chopped 92 auditing positions from the
civil service.
“On the Clement case, team Harper’s strategy appears to be to simply ride out the criticism,” wrote Globe and Mail columnist
Lawrence Martin at the time. “Stonewall the media and the opposition
until fatigue with the issue has set in and everyone moves on. It has
worked in the past. It will likely work now.”
In fact, unlike his predecessors, Harper has seemed Teflon-like in
respect to how corruption scandals have clung to him. Even the trial of
Senator Mike Duffy has not dented his veneer to any great extent –
although this may soon change.
Yet corruption is among the litany of reasons why Stephen Harper
might go down in history as Canada’s worst prime minister (a case we
began to make here in Part 1 of this two-part series).
A more recent example of Harper’s proclivity for corruption was
buried in the 2015 budget. After the government got rid of the long
gun-registry in 2012, the RCMP was ordered to destroy its records. By
then, however, an access to information request for this data had been
made. The RCMP eviscerated the information anyway – which is a criminal
offence if an access request is being processed.
Suzanne Legault,
Canada’s information commissioner, recommended charges be laid against
the responsible RCMP members – which included high-ranking officers.
But in its most recent omnibus bill the Harper government simply
rewrote the access laws retroactively to erase the RCMP's mishandling of
gun registry records – in order to protect these officers from facing
criminal charges.
This, of course, sets a precedent of simply arbitrarily changing
laws in order to protect political allies. According to Legault: “We
could, for example, with this bill, set a precedent whereby, if there
were findings of electoral fraud, the government could just pass a law
and say: ‘No, these provisions never applied.'”
This kind of behavior is one reason Christian Nadeau, a political
philosopher at the Université de Montréal and author of a 2010 book
about Harper, Rogue in Power, says the Harper government is “an
unjust government and an anti-democratic government… It’s a whole
enterprise of rebuilding not only the institutions but the political
culture in Canada. Ten years ago [the actions of the Tories] would be
seen as something very bad and very unacceptable. But now what they’re
doing seems normal.”
His corruption record
When investigative journalist Stevie Cameron – who wrote two books
about the Mulroney era – compares Harper and Mulroney on their
corruption track records, she says: “Mulroney was a crook and corrupt
[but] I don’t think Harper is corrupt financially. I think he’s corrupt
in so many other ways… I don’t think he’s interested in money. I think
he’s much more interested in power and secrecy.”
Take the Senate spending scandal, which has so far embroiled Tory
senators Mike Duffy, Pamela Wallin and Patrick Brazeau. Initially this
story seemed straightforward – senators abusing the public purse by
spending money on non-Senate related business and travel.
But what’s also emerged are the lengths Harper and his staff have
gone to try and bury the scandal. First there was $32,000 allegedly
offered by the Conservative Party’s fundraising arm to cover Duffy’s
travel expenses. And then there was Nigel Wright, Harper’s chief of
staff, ponying up $90,000 to do the same thing.
In 2013, the Senate hired the auditing firm Deloitte to look into
the expense claims of certain senators, including Duffy. When Duffy’s
audit was finished, the report on its findings was diverted to the Prime
Minister’s Office where it was revised before being sent on to the
Senate. Two Tory senators assisted with the alterations.
“I always felt that the most important part of the Duffy fiasco is
not the dubious expenses of a cheese-eating monkey like Duffy,” says
journalist Michael Harris, author of Party of One, last year’s
bestseller about Harper’s reign, “but the fact that the prime minister
reached into the Senate in the middle of the forensic audit and got the
published report before the Senate did and got changes through
controlling the committee of internal economy… What we had was the act
of undermining another body of Parliament in an outrageous way that goes
to the heart of this guy’s psyche.”
What’s also been lost in the Senate scandal was the fact that
senators like Duffy and Wallin were using their taxpayer-funded
positions to bankroll their jobs as fundraisers for the Conservative
Party. Duffy, in particular, was the star speaker at fundraising events
and Tory riding associations across Canada. For example, in the summer
of 2009, he hosted a $100,000 town-hall event for Harper in Cambridge,
Ontario. He hosted a telethon hall for Julian Fantino in 2010 during the
by-election that sent the former Toronto police chief to Ottawa.
Michael Bate, editor of gossip magazine Frank, has compiled
a list of Tories charged with one crime or another since 2006, which
includes Michael Sona, Bruce Carson, Arthur Porter, Devinder Shory,
Peter Penashue, Saulie Zajdel, Rahim Jaffer, Dean Del Mastro, James
Bezan and Nathan Jacobson.
“Comparing the Harperites to the [Chretien Liberals], I’d say
they’re probably equal in appetite,” says Bate. “The Liberals had better
table manners, a sense of how much they could get away with. The Tories
just dig in with both hooves, like there’s no tomorrow.”
Other scandals of note during Harper’s tenure include:
The F-35 jet fighter contract. The plan was to buy
65 of Lockheed Martin’s F-35 fighters with the Tories claiming the price
tag would be $9-billion to purchase and $7-billion to maintain. Yet the
contract was never put out to tender – even though Canadian law
requires this must happen for major defense purchases. A 2012 Auditor
General’s report said the government did not conduct a fair competition
or proper due diligence. Moreover, when the government signed an
agreement with Lockheed Martin in the fall of 2006, unlike previous
agreements, this one did not guarantee a minimum amount of production be
done in Canada. Prime Minister Stephen Harper with F-35 model in January 2011. Photo from PMO archives
Soon the price tag became wishful thinking. The
Parliamentary Budget Officer Kevin Page estimated the fighter would
actually cost nearly $30-billion over 30 years. The Harper government
condemned Page, even though he was vindicated by estimates drawn up by
the Auditor General. Page even said the Harper government appeared to be
keeping two sets of books on the F-35 - one in secret, and another for
the public. One other estimate suggested the total cost could be as high
as $126 billion – or $110-billion more than the Tories originally said.
Yet the Tories refused to answer questions about these estimates, and
religiously stuck to the story the planes would cost less. Only after
years of denial did the government shelve the order for the time being.
The in and out scandal. During the 2006 election,
the Tories were accused of getting around spending limits by
transferring money between the party and its riding offices. Having
reached their $18.3-million spending limit, the Conservatives
transferred $1.3-million to 67 ridings, which then funneled it back to
the national party to spend on advertising. An investigation of this
laundering was stymied by Tories sitting on the Standing Committee on
Procedure and House Affairs. In 2011, four members of the party
(including two senators) were charged for their involvement in the
scheme – and the party forced to repay $230,198. Nigel Wright, Harper’s
former chief of staff, was listed among those involved.
Bruce Carson influence-peddling scandal. A former
senior adviser in Harper’s PMO, Carson was a disbarred lawyer who had
gone to jail for numerous charges of fraud prior to joining Harper’s
inner circle. In 2012, Carson was charged with influence-peddling
following allegations he’d lobbied ministerial staff at the Department
of Aboriginal and Northern Development on behalf of his then fiancée
(and former escort), Michele McPherson, who acted as an intermediary for
an Ottawa-based water purification company H20 Pros. McPherson stood to
earn commissions from any sales to First Nations reserves. Last year,
the RCMP hit Carson with more charges of illegal lobbying.
His foreign policy record
Brian Mulroney gave an interview with CTV’s Power Play last summer where, among other things, he lambasted the Harper government for its record on foreign affairs.
“When Canada, for the first time in our history, loses a vote at the
United Nations to become a member of the Security Council . . . to
Portugal, which was on the verge of bankruptcy at the time, you should
look in the mirror and say: ‘Houston, I think we have a problem,’” said
Mulroney. “We’re in the big leagues... so we have to conduct ourselves
in that way. We can’t be out-riders.”
Mulroney also chastised Harper for his poor relations with U.S.
President Barack Obama, suggesting the prime minister doesn’t have the
kind of close ties that allow him to call the Oval Office and ask for
bilateral back-up. “If you can’t do that, you don’t have much clout
internationally.”
Indeed, back in 2010, when Canada sought a seat on the UN’s Security
Council and lost to Portugal – the first time in 50 years Canada had
never gained a seat – it reflected how other nations had become appalled
with Harper’s foreign policy.
First off, there was his move away from giving aid to Africa.
In fact, under Harper, aid was increasingly doled out based less on
need as much as economic opportunity for Canadian companies. In 2013,
the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) was dissolved. Last
year, Harper also announced he would prohibit Canadian funding for
safe, legal abortions in poor countries.
Under Harper, Canada’s peacekeeping force has been almost
eradicated. Once the world’s number-one provider of peacekeeping
personnel, Canada now ranks 67th on the UN’s peacekeeping
contributors’ list, or a grand total of 122 people. “We’ve gone from
being a major contributor to a situation today where we’re an
insignificant contributor at a time when UN peacekeeping is at an
all-time high,” says Peggy Mason, president of the Rideau Institute, an
Ottawa-based foreign policy and defense advocacy group.
“Every indication of the Harper government is they have no
interest in peacekeeping – which is part and parcel of their hostile
attitude towards the UN.”
Harper has also displayed hypocrisy when it comes to China.
When first elected prime minister in 2006, he routinely condemned
China’s human-rights record and promised to not trade “Canadian values”
for the “almighty dollar.” By 2010, Harper had changed his tune,
allowing Sinopec, the Chinese petroleum giant, to buy a stake in
Syncrude that permits it to decide whether its bitumen is refined in
Canada or shipped abroad. Two years later, Harper did not stop the
Chinese state-owned oil company CNOOC from buying the Calgary-based
resource company Nexen for $15.1-billion. Prime Minister Stephen Harper with Chinese president Xi Jinping in China, November 10, 2014. Photo from PMO website.
Moreover, there are pipelines that will send
bitumen from the oil sands to China – including Northern Gateway and
Kinder Morgan – which the Harper government has wholeheartedly endorsed.
Even more alarmingly, Harper secretly signed the Foreign Investment
Promotion and Protection Agreement (FIPA) with China while attending an
APEC summit in Vladivostok, Russia in 2012. What’s the problem with this
agreement?
China has invested over $30-billion in the Canadian energy sector
alone, and its companies are significant investors in the Enbridge
Northern Gateway pipeline. Yet the FIPA agreement would allow China to
sue Canada if the pipeline was not built.
"Chinese investors can sue Canada for any actions by the federal
government or the B.C. government (or legislature or courts) relating to
Chinese assets connected to the [Enbridge] Northern Gateway pipeline,"
Osgoode Hall law professor and investment treaty expert Gus Van Harten told The Vancouver Observer last September. Van Harten argued that the deal was not only disadvantageous to Canada, but also potentially unconstitutional.
"More troubling, there is no requirement in the treaty for the
federal government to make public the fact of a Chinese investor's
lawsuit against Canada until an award has been issued by a tribunal.
This means that the federal government could settle the lawsuit by
paying out public money before an award is issued, and we would never
know."
One small B.C. First Nation, the Hupacasath, issued a legal
challenge in 2012 against FIPA, arguing that the deal threatened
constitutionally protected Indigenous land rights, and that it was
signed without any consultation. The Federal Court and Federal Court of
appeal dismissed the case, claiming any claims of FIPA’s impact were
“speculative.”
Despite widespread public opposition in Canada from citizens, First
Nations and businesses, FIPA was quietly ratified in September 2014,
locking Canadians into the deal with China until 2045.
Meanwhile, one of Harper’s most polarizing foreign policy causes has been Israel.
As Israel has grown increasingly isolated due to its treatment of the
Palestinians in the Occupied Territories – as well as building illegal
settlements on this land – the Harper government has become one of the
country’s most zealous supporters.
Since Harper became prime minister, Israel has invaded Lebanon –
killing up to 1,125 Lebanese (as compared to 159 Israelis) and launched
two invasions of the Gaza strip, the first in 2008-’09 that led to 1,434
Palestinian casualties (as compared to 13 Israelis) and then last year,
leading to 2,139 Palestinian deaths and 11,000 wounded (as compared to
73 Israeli deaths and 556 wounded).
In 2010, when six Turkish ships set sail for Gaza to deliver 10,000
tonnes of humanitarian aid to relieve Israel’s blockade, Israeli
commandos stormed the boats in international waters and killed 10
activists.
Despite international condemnation over what was seen as Israel’s
overkill in these instances, the Harper government has consistently
rushed to Israel’s defense and been quick to brand Palestinians and
their organizations as “terrorists.”
“From my personal point of view, I would have a great deal of
respect for Mr. Harper if he had taken a more balanced view in that
sphere,” says Bernie Farber, former head of the Canadian Jewish
Congress. “To drive wedge issues between the [Jewish and Palestinian]
communities is not in my view the way to do politics in this country… We
have to find things that bring us together as opposed to driving us
apart.” Harper at Western Wall in Jerusalem, January 21, 2014. CP photo.
Harper has a close affinity with the current government of Israel, led
by the hard-liner Benjamin Netanyahu, although Netanyahu’s party won
only 23 per cent of the vote in the most recent election. Moreover,
during that campaign, Netanyahu pledged to never negotiate a two-state
solution with the Palestinians and made thinly racist comments on the
eve of the vote, saying “Arab voters are heading to the polling stations
in droves” as a warning to voters to back his Likud party.
In fact, Canada has sided with Israel to thwart Palestinians efforts
to have their own state: in 2012, Canada was only one of nine countries
in the UN that voted against Palestinians achieving statehood. Since
2007, it has cut off aid to the Palestinian Authority, voted against all
UN resolutions recognizing the rights of Palestinians and complained
bitterly when Palestine was admitted as a full member state to UNESCO.
Not surprisingly, Harper’s foreign policy has alienated Canada’s
Arab and Muslim communities. The government doggedly fought to keep Omar
Khadr behind bars, although he was only 15 when involved in a firefight
in Afghanistan that led to the death of a US soldier. In 2009, the
federal government cut its $1-million annual funding for the Canadian
Arab Federation (CAF) due to the organization’s criticisms of Israel.
Conservative fundraising letters in recent months have disparaged Muslim women wearing niqabs
at citizenship oath ceremonies, saying “they should embrace our
culture” and “that’s not the way we do things,” and even referencing
Al-Shabaab threats against Canada in their ads.
“For years the Canadian government had charted a reasonable,
unbiased or not strongly biased attitude towards Muslims,” says Atif
Kubursi, former president of the National Council on Canada-Arab
Relations and emeritus professor of economics at McMaster University.
“But when Mr. Harper came there was a major shift.”
And then there is Harper’s decision to send fighter jets to Iraq to do battle with ISIS,
costing $360-million this year. The Chrétien government refused to send
troops to Iraq in 2003, recognizing it was a foolhardy venture.
Moreover, evidence has since emerged that the American invasion so
destabilized Iraq it helped give birth to ISIS and other jihadist
groups. “I think [Harper’s bombing of ISIS] is a completely wrongheaded
strategy that is ineffective, counter-productive and possibly playing
into the hands of ISIS,” says Peggy Mason of the Rideau Institute.
“Number one – the bombing campaign doesn’t work. And ISIS uses it to
recruit people from all over the region – not just foreign fighters.”
In fact, the war on ISIS has also been used by the Harper government
to whip up support for its draconian Bill C-51 anti-terrorism
legislation, stoking fears about terrorist attacks on Canadian soil on
the eve of the October election.
His cultural record
Stephen Harper has never hidden his contempt for the cultural
sector. During the 2008 election he claimed that “ordinary people” don't
care about arts funding and have no sympathy for “rich” artists who
gather at galas to whine about their grants. By then he’d cut
$45-million to arts and culture programs.
So it’s no surprise that the one main cultural institution Harper
seems determined to destroy is the CBC. When Ian Morrison, the long-time
spokesperson of Friends of Canadian Broadcasting, is asked to
characterize the Harper government’s attitude towards the CBC, he
replies: “Number one – subterfuge. If there is a hidden agenda and there
are 50 items on that hidden agenda, CBC is near the top.”
Morrison says during the 2011 election Tory candidates professed
support for the CBC but promptly began “sabotaging” it once the election
was over. Indeed, in his 2012 budget, finance minister Jim Flaherty
immediately cut $115-million from the CBC’s budget.
Even before Harper became prime minister, the CBC was one of the
most poorly-funded public broadcasters in the world. Canada’s level of
government support for the CBC ranks near the bottom compared with that
of other Western industrialized nations: A 2006 report showed that
Canada stood 16th out of 18 nations in per-capita funding of public broadcasters, at $33 per citizen, compared with an average of $80.
At the time Harper became prime minister, the CBC’s operating budget
was down to $1.1-billion (all figures in 2014 dollars) and peaked at
$1.15-billion in 2007. Since then, it’s steadily declined and now stands
at $929-million and is set to continue to fall. The CBC says it will
cut 25 percent of its workforce by 2020 – or up to 1,500 jobs.
In 2013, the federal government surreptitiously placed the CBC under
the Financial Administration Act, making it subject to review by the
Treasury Board. This means the board can scrutinize how the CBC spends
its money, in particular on labour. “The impact of that was to give the
Treasury Board a supervisory role over management,” says Morrison.
Harper also stacked the CBC’s board with his political supporters.
Since 2007, the CBC has been presided over by Tory donor and lawyer
Hubert T. Lacroix, who used to work at the Canada’s most powerful
corporate law firm, McCarthy Tétrault, as a business attorney. Lacroix
has embraced, without complaint, every effort by the Harper government
to downsize the CBC. Meanwhile, nine of the CBC board’s 11 members are
Tory donors, most of whom have business or corporate law backgrounds.
The ideological shift at the CBC under Harper has been noticeable
too, where pro-business shows have proliferated while investigative
programs have been cut.
Harper has also attacked Canada’s historical institutions. In 2012,
Harper chopped the budget of the national library and archives, making
it more difficult for historians to research the country’s past. “The
library and archives have almost been destroyed by this government,”
says Ian McKay, a professor of history at Queen’s University. “The cuts
to the archives were breathtaking – not cuts to some people but
cancelation of whole programs. The things that got saved were anything
to do with military history.”
Moreover, McKay says the Harper government has also changed our
citizenship guide to reflect a narrow, pro-military and pro-business
view of Canadian history, “very much emphasizing Canada’s role in war
and [showing that] true Canadian heroes are warriors.”
Harper also changed the Museum of Civilization in Ottawa to the
Museum of Canadian History, which emphasizes Canada’s role in military
engagements. “They have taken a world-class museum facility and focused
on a particular martial aspect,” says McKay.
When asked about Harper’s overall legacy, McKay replies:
“I would say it has been an unmitigated disaster. I don’t think we’ve
ever had a prime minister who’s failed to articulate, to the extent
this one has, a vision of the country. He’s essentially ruled the
country as a CEO and given Canadians zero inspiration. I would be
hard-pressed to find one moment where Harper has made us feel proud of
Canada.”
No comments:
Post a Comment