Racism: A legal argument to have Stephen Harper removed from
Parliament
I don’t know how much treachery a Canadian should stomach from this traitor and
sponsor of genocide in the Middle East - crimes which are punishable by
execution in the international courts.
The burqa has become the latest attack on our Charter of
Rights and Freedom. Harper’s newest electoral strategy is to create a wedge
between the varying political and religious sects in this country, and
continually increase the fear barometer – the same politics employed by Neo-Conservative/Zionist
Satanists.
Harper in his newest political obscenity has managed to indirectly,
knowingly or unknowingly, attack many religious groups and personal life-styles.
This attack on the burqa is a direct racist attack on Thomas Mulcair as well.
One might ask why, and the answer is clearly visible:
1.A male darning a beard, would in many cases, be
completely unrecognizable if he shaved his beard and hair. Mr. Mulcair, would
Canadians recognize you with no beard and a bald landscape? The answer would be
intriguing.
2.A male darning a beard and a turban could be
completely unrecognizable if he shaved his beard, removed the turban and shaved
his hair. Another terrorist in the making!
3.What about religious denominations that require
women to wear disguises such as wigs?
4.Today’s tattoos and body-piercing can transform
the body to unrecognizable states – should we ban this form of personal
expression? Remember, that some tattoos can be temporary.
I still do not understand why Stephen Harper is eligible to participate in this
Federal election. A traitor, thief, liar and sponsor to murder should be in
jail, not on the campaign trail. I have attached a poem I wrote about five
years anticipating this newest political farce.
Thank you,
Joseph Pede
The Burqa and the Beard
The Burqa and the Beard both stir the imagination
Underneath one layer of disguise there exists another
Religion and tradition are the two boundaries
Laziness and fashion create the two in-betweens
The beard is an out-poring of the facial facade
It hides the true intentions of authority
A burqa conceals an entire persona
The silky garb fortifies the visage of the mysterious face
The Rabbi and Imam make fertile their beards
Their wisdom matures as the hair spasms from black to silver and finally gold
Men ponder the passion inside the burqa, and
Discard its reality should it not favour the beard
The burqa is not of Islam
It is a guise intended to impede vociferous thoughts
Worn both to dignify and ostracize the flesh
Its intended purpose is to confuse chastity
A beard creates the look of age
It has migrated from authority to a joyful liberalism
Today stubble naively makes folly of the beard
We will soon see the beard angrily emerge from behind the burqa.
Illustration of Prime Minister Stephen Harper by Victor Juhasz for National Observer
“Brian Mulroney was an appalling prime minister, appalling. But
if I had to pick one prime minister over the other [between Harper and
Mulroney], I would pick Mulroney.”
– Stevie Cameron, author of On the Take, the 1994 bestseller about corruption during the Mulroney years.
In the summer of 2010, U.S. President Barack Obama, British Prime
Minister David Cameron and other world leaders arrived at a swanky
resort located two hours north of Toronto to take part in the annual G8
Summit. As it turned out, the resort lies in the riding of then federal
Industry Minister Tony Clement.
At that time, no one knew that Clement had lifted $50-million from
the public purse – money originally allotted by parliament for
alleviating congestion at Canada’s borders – and spent it beautifying
his Parry Sound-Muskoka riding on things like parks, walkways, toilets
and gazebos. He would later claim the money was dispersed for the G8
Summit.
But when Auditor General Shelia Fraser investigated what happened to
the $50-million, she could find little paperwork showing how it was
decided the money be spent. Documents later unearthed through the Access
to Information Act showed Clement was encouraging mayors in his riding
to apply for this cash prior to the 2008 election – and used federal
civil servants to help dole it out. The NDP later accused Clement of
using the money as a “slush fund” to better his chances of getting
re-elected.
Still, when the $50-million scandal broke in 2011, Clement was not
dropped from cabinet or even reprimanded. Instead, Prime Minister
Stephen Harper put him in charge of the Treasury Board – the very entity
designed to oversee spending, ethics and accountability in government.
That same year, the Conservatives chopped 92 auditing positions from the
civil service.
“On the Clement case, team Harper’s strategy appears to be to simply ride out the criticism,” wrote Globe and Mail columnist
Lawrence Martin at the time. “Stonewall the media and the opposition
until fatigue with the issue has set in and everyone moves on. It has
worked in the past. It will likely work now.”
In fact, unlike his predecessors, Harper has seemed Teflon-like in
respect to how corruption scandals have clung to him. Even the trial of
Senator Mike Duffy has not dented his veneer to any great extent –
although this may soon change.
Yet corruption is among the litany of reasons why Stephen Harper
might go down in history as Canada’s worst prime minister (a case we
began to make here in Part 1 of this two-part series).
A more recent example of Harper’s proclivity for corruption was
buried in the 2015 budget. After the government got rid of the long
gun-registry in 2012, the RCMP was ordered to destroy its records. By
then, however, an access to information request for this data had been
made. The RCMP eviscerated the information anyway – which is a criminal
offence if an access request is being processed.
Suzanne Legault,
Canada’s information commissioner, recommended charges be laid against
the responsible RCMP members – which included high-ranking officers.
But in its most recent omnibus bill the Harper government simply
rewrote the access laws retroactively to erase the RCMP's mishandling of
gun registry records – in order to protect these officers from facing
criminal charges.
This, of course, sets a precedent of simply arbitrarily changing
laws in order to protect political allies. According to Legault: “We
could, for example, with this bill, set a precedent whereby, if there
were findings of electoral fraud, the government could just pass a law
and say: ‘No, these provisions never applied.'”
When investigative journalist Stevie Cameron – who wrote two books
about the Mulroney era – compares Harper and Mulroney on their
corruption track records, she says: “Mulroney was a crook and corrupt
[but] I don’t think Harper is corrupt financially. I think he’s corrupt
in so many other ways… I don’t think he’s interested in money. I think
he’s much more interested in power and secrecy.”
Take the Senate spending scandal, which has so far embroiled Tory
senators Mike Duffy, Pamela Wallin and Patrick Brazeau. Initially this
story seemed straightforward – senators abusing the public purse by
spending money on non-Senate related business and travel.
But what’s also emerged are the lengths Harper and his staff have
gone to try and bury the scandal. First there was $32,000 allegedly
offered by the Conservative Party’s fundraising arm to cover Duffy’s
travel expenses. And then there was Nigel Wright, Harper’s chief of
staff, ponying up $90,000 to do the same thing.
In 2013, the Senate hired the auditing firm Deloitte to look into
the expense claims of certain senators, including Duffy. When Duffy’s
audit was finished, the report on its findings was diverted to the Prime
Minister’s Office where it was revised before being sent on to the
Senate. Two Tory senators assisted with the alterations.
“I always felt that the most important part of the Duffy fiasco is
not the dubious expenses of a cheese-eating monkey like Duffy,” says
journalist Michael Harris, author of Party of One, last year’s
bestseller about Harper’s reign, “but the fact that the prime minister
reached into the Senate in the middle of the forensic audit and got the
published report before the Senate did and got changes through
controlling the committee of internal economy… What we had was the act
of undermining another body of Parliament in an outrageous way that goes
to the heart of this guy’s psyche.”
What’s also been lost in the Senate scandal was the fact that
senators like Duffy and Wallin were using their taxpayer-funded
positions to bankroll their jobs as fundraisers for the Conservative
Party. Duffy, in particular, was the star speaker at fundraising events
and Tory riding associations across Canada. For example, in the summer
of 2009, he hosted a $100,000 town-hall event for Harper in Cambridge,
Ontario. He hosted a telethon hall for Julian Fantino in 2010 during the
by-election that sent the former Toronto police chief to Ottawa.
Michael Bate, editor of gossip magazine Frank, has compiled
a list of Tories charged with one crime or another since 2006, which
includes Michael Sona, Bruce Carson, Arthur Porter, Devinder Shory,
Peter Penashue, Saulie Zajdel, Rahim Jaffer, Dean Del Mastro, James
Bezan and Nathan Jacobson.
“Comparing the Harperites to the [Chretien Liberals], I’d say
they’re probably equal in appetite,” says Bate. “The Liberals had better
table manners, a sense of how much they could get away with. The Tories
just dig in with both hooves, like there’s no tomorrow.”
Other scandals of note during Harper’s tenure include:
The F-35 jet fighter contract. The plan was to buy
65 of Lockheed Martin’s F-35 fighters with the Tories claiming the price
tag would be $9-billion to purchase and $7-billion to maintain. Yet the
contract was never put out to tender – even though Canadian law
requires this must happen for major defense purchases. A 2012 Auditor
General’s report said the government did not conduct a fair competition
or proper due diligence. Moreover, when the government signed an
agreement with Lockheed Martin in the fall of 2006, unlike previous
agreements, this one did not guarantee a minimum amount of production be
done in Canada. Prime Minister Stephen Harper with F-35 model in January 2011. Photo from PMO archives
Soon the price tag became wishful thinking. The
Parliamentary Budget Officer Kevin Page estimated the fighter would
actually cost nearly $30-billion over 30 years. The Harper government
condemned Page, even though he was vindicated by estimates drawn up by
the Auditor General. Page even said the Harper government appeared to be
keeping two sets of books on the F-35 - one in secret, and another for
the public. One other estimate suggested the total cost could be as high
as $126 billion – or $110-billion more than the Tories originally said.
Yet the Tories refused to answer questions about these estimates, and
religiously stuck to the story the planes would cost less. Only after
years of denial did the government shelve the order for the time being.
The in and out scandal. During the 2006 election,
the Tories were accused of getting around spending limits by
transferring money between the party and its riding offices. Having
reached their $18.3-million spending limit, the Conservatives
transferred $1.3-million to 67 ridings, which then funneled it back to
the national party to spend on advertising. An investigation of this
laundering was stymied by Tories sitting on the Standing Committee on
Procedure and House Affairs. In 2011, four members of the party
(including two senators) were charged for their involvement in the
scheme – and the party forced to repay $230,198. Nigel Wright, Harper’s
former chief of staff, was listed among those involved.
Brian Mulroney gave an interview with CTV’s Power Play last summer where, among other things, he lambasted the Harper government for its record on foreign affairs.
“When Canada, for the first time in our history, loses a vote at the
United Nations to become a member of the Security Council . . . to
Portugal, which was on the verge of bankruptcy at the time, you should
look in the mirror and say: ‘Houston, I think we have a problem,’” said
Mulroney. “We’re in the big leagues... so we have to conduct ourselves
in that way. We can’t be out-riders.”
Mulroney also chastised Harper for his poor relations with U.S.
President Barack Obama, suggesting the prime minister doesn’t have the
kind of close ties that allow him to call the Oval Office and ask for
bilateral back-up. “If you can’t do that, you don’t have much clout
internationally.”
Indeed, back in 2010, when Canada sought a seat on the UN’s Security
Council and lost to Portugal – the first time in 50 years Canada had
never gained a seat – it reflected how other nations had become appalled
with Harper’s foreign policy.
First off, there was his move away from giving aid to Africa.
In fact, under Harper, aid was increasingly doled out based less on
need as much as economic opportunity for Canadian companies. In 2013,
the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) was dissolved. Last
year, Harper also announced he would prohibit Canadian funding for
safe, legal abortions in poor countries.
Under Harper, Canada’s peacekeeping force has been almost
eradicated. Once the world’s number-one provider of peacekeeping
personnel, Canada now ranks 67th on the UN’s peacekeeping
contributors’ list, or a grand total of 122 people. “We’ve gone from
being a major contributor to a situation today where we’re an
insignificant contributor at a time when UN peacekeeping is at an
all-time high,” says Peggy Mason, president of the Rideau Institute, an
Ottawa-based foreign policy and defense advocacy group.
“Every indication of the Harper government is they have no
interest in peacekeeping – which is part and parcel of their hostile
attitude towards the UN.”
Harper has also displayed hypocrisy when it comes to China.
When first elected prime minister in 2006, he routinely condemned
China’s human-rights record and promised to not trade “Canadian values”
for the “almighty dollar.” By 2010, Harper had changed his tune,
allowing Sinopec, the Chinese petroleum giant, to buy a stake in
Syncrude that permits it to decide whether its bitumen is refined in
Canada or shipped abroad. Two years later, Harper did not stop the
Chinese state-owned oil company CNOOC from buying the Calgary-based
resource company Nexen for $15.1-billion. Prime Minister Stephen Harper with Chinese president Xi Jinping in China, November 10, 2014. Photo from PMO website.
Moreover, there are pipelines that will send
bitumen from the oil sands to China – including Northern Gateway and
Kinder Morgan – which the Harper government has wholeheartedly endorsed.
Even more alarmingly, Harper secretly signed the Foreign Investment
Promotion and Protection Agreement (FIPA) with China while attending an
APEC summit in Vladivostok, Russia in 2012. What’s the problem with this
agreement?
China has invested over $30-billion in the Canadian energy sector
alone, and its companies are significant investors in the Enbridge
Northern Gateway pipeline. Yet the FIPA agreement would allow China to
sue Canada if the pipeline was not built.
"Chinese investors can sue Canada for any actions by the federal
government or the B.C. government (or legislature or courts) relating to
Chinese assets connected to the [Enbridge] Northern Gateway pipeline,"
Osgoode Hall law professor and investment treaty expert Gus Van Harten told The Vancouver Observer last September. Van Harten argued that the deal was not only disadvantageous to Canada, but also potentially unconstitutional.
"More troubling, there is no requirement in the treaty for the
federal government to make public the fact of a Chinese investor's
lawsuit against Canada until an award has been issued by a tribunal.
This means that the federal government could settle the lawsuit by
paying out public money before an award is issued, and we would never
know."
One small B.C. First Nation, the Hupacasath, issued a legal
challenge in 2012 against FIPA, arguing that the deal threatened
constitutionally protected Indigenous land rights, and that it was
signed without any consultation. The Federal Court and Federal Court of
appeal dismissed the case, claiming any claims of FIPA’s impact were
“speculative.”
Despite widespread public opposition in Canada from citizens, First
Nations and businesses, FIPA was quietly ratified in September 2014,
locking Canadians into the deal with China until 2045.
Meanwhile, one of Harper’s most polarizing foreign policy causes has been Israel.
As Israel has grown increasingly isolated due to its treatment of the
Palestinians in the Occupied Territories – as well as building illegal
settlements on this land – the Harper government has become one of the
country’s most zealous supporters.
Since Harper became prime minister, Israel has invaded Lebanon –
killing up to 1,125 Lebanese (as compared to 159 Israelis) and launched
two invasions of the Gaza strip, the first in 2008-’09 that led to 1,434
Palestinian casualties (as compared to 13 Israelis) and then last year,
leading to 2,139 Palestinian deaths and 11,000 wounded (as compared to
73 Israeli deaths and 556 wounded).
In 2010, when six Turkish ships set sail for Gaza to deliver 10,000
tonnes of humanitarian aid to relieve Israel’s blockade, Israeli
commandos stormed the boats in international waters and killed 10
activists.
Despite international condemnation over what was seen as Israel’s
overkill in these instances, the Harper government has consistently
rushed to Israel’s defense and been quick to brand Palestinians and
their organizations as “terrorists.”
“From my personal point of view, I would have a great deal of
respect for Mr. Harper if he had taken a more balanced view in that
sphere,” says Bernie Farber, former head of the Canadian Jewish
Congress. “To drive wedge issues between the [Jewish and Palestinian]
communities is not in my view the way to do politics in this country… We
have to find things that bring us together as opposed to driving us
apart.” Harper at Western Wall in Jerusalem, January 21, 2014. CP photo.
Harper has a close affinity with the current government of Israel, led
by the hard-liner Benjamin Netanyahu, although Netanyahu’s party won
only 23 per cent of the vote in the most recent election. Moreover,
during that campaign, Netanyahu pledged to never negotiate a two-state
solution with the Palestinians and made thinly racist comments on the
eve of the vote, saying “Arab voters are heading to the polling stations
in droves” as a warning to voters to back his Likud party.
In fact, Canada has sided with Israel to thwart Palestinians efforts
to have their own state: in 2012, Canada was only one of nine countries
in the UN that voted against Palestinians achieving statehood. Since
2007, it has cut off aid to the Palestinian Authority, voted against all
UN resolutions recognizing the rights of Palestinians and complained
bitterly when Palestine was admitted as a full member state to UNESCO.
Not surprisingly, Harper’s foreign policy has alienated Canada’s
Arab and Muslim communities. The government doggedly fought to keep Omar
Khadr behind bars, although he was only 15 when involved in a firefight
in Afghanistan that led to the death of a US soldier. In 2009, the
federal government cut its $1-million annual funding for the Canadian
Arab Federation (CAF) due to the organization’s criticisms of Israel.
Conservative fundraising letters in recent months have disparaged Muslim women wearing niqabs
at citizenship oath ceremonies, saying “they should embrace our
culture” and “that’s not the way we do things,” and even referencing
Al-Shabaab threats against Canada in their ads.
“For years the Canadian government had charted a reasonable,
unbiased or not strongly biased attitude towards Muslims,” says Atif
Kubursi, former president of the National Council on Canada-Arab
Relations and emeritus professor of economics at McMaster University.
“But when Mr. Harper came there was a major shift.”
In fact, the war on ISIS has also been used by the Harper government
to whip up support for its draconian Bill C-51 anti-terrorism
legislation, stoking fears about terrorist attacks on Canadian soil on
the eve of the October election.
His cultural record
Stephen Harper has never hidden his contempt for the cultural
sector. During the 2008 election he claimed that “ordinary people” don't
care about arts funding and have no sympathy for “rich” artists who
gather at galas to whine about their grants. By then he’d cut
$45-million to arts and culture programs.
So it’s no surprise that the one main cultural institution Harper
seems determined to destroy is the CBC. When Ian Morrison, the long-time
spokesperson of Friends of Canadian Broadcasting, is asked to
characterize the Harper government’s attitude towards the CBC, he
replies: “Number one – subterfuge. If there is a hidden agenda and there
are 50 items on that hidden agenda, CBC is near the top.”
Morrison says during the 2011 election Tory candidates professed
support for the CBC but promptly began “sabotaging” it once the election
was over. Indeed, in his 2012 budget, finance minister Jim Flaherty
immediately cut $115-million from the CBC’s budget.
Even before Harper became prime minister, the CBC was one of the
most poorly-funded public broadcasters in the world. Canada’s level of
government support for the CBC ranks near the bottom compared with that
of other Western industrialized nations: A 2006 report showed that
Canada stood 16th out of 18 nations in per-capita funding of public broadcasters, at $33 per citizen, compared with an average of $80.
At the time Harper became prime minister, the CBC’s operating budget
was down to $1.1-billion (all figures in 2014 dollars) and peaked at
$1.15-billion in 2007. Since then, it’s steadily declined and now stands
at $929-million and is set to continue to fall. The CBC says it will
cut 25 percent of its workforce by 2020 – or up to 1,500 jobs.
In 2013, the federal government surreptitiously placed the CBC under
the Financial Administration Act, making it subject to review by the
Treasury Board. This means the board can scrutinize how the CBC spends
its money, in particular on labour. “The impact of that was to give the
Treasury Board a supervisory role over management,” says Morrison.
The ideological shift at the CBC under Harper has been noticeable
too, where pro-business shows have proliferated while investigative
programs have been cut.
Harper has also attacked Canada’s historical institutions. In 2012,
Harper chopped the budget of the national library and archives, making
it more difficult for historians to research the country’s past. “The
library and archives have almost been destroyed by this government,”
says Ian McKay, a professor of history at Queen’s University. “The cuts
to the archives were breathtaking – not cuts to some people but
cancelation of whole programs. The things that got saved were anything
to do with military history.”
Moreover, McKay says the Harper government has also changed our
citizenship guide to reflect a narrow, pro-military and pro-business
view of Canadian history, “very much emphasizing Canada’s role in war
and [showing that] true Canadian heroes are warriors.”
Harper also changed the Museum of Civilization in Ottawa to the
Museum of Canadian History, which emphasizes Canada’s role in military
engagements. “They have taken a world-class museum facility and focused
on a particular martial aspect,” says McKay.
When asked about Harper’s overall legacy, McKay replies:
“I would say it has been an unmitigated disaster. I don’t think we’ve
ever had a prime minister who’s failed to articulate, to the extent
this one has, a vision of the country. He’s essentially ruled the
country as a CEO and given Canadians zero inspiration. I would be
hard-pressed to find one moment where Harper has made us feel proud of
Canada.”
Illustration by Victor Juhasz for National Observer
“I think Harper… can be vindictive, certainly not always grateful
for what people have done for him in the past… So you can say he’s
ruthless, which is probably true… Maybe that’s a personal failing.”
– Tom Flanagan, former Harper adviser, campaign manager and University of Calgary political scientist
Five weeks after Stephen Harper won his majority government in 2011, Maclean’s magazine ran a story asking experts to name Canada’s best prime ministers. Harper ranked 11th on the list.
Stephen Azzi, a Carleton University historian who co-authored the Maclean’s
piece, says he doubts very much Harper would have budged on the list if
their survey were conducted today. “All of the prime ministers we
consider successful have some major accomplishment they can point to –
Harper doesn’t have that,” he explains. “His accomplishment first of all
is winning power and staying in power and then there are a series of
minor things that his supporters like. But it will be hard for future
generations to remember him for these things.”
On the Maclean’s list, the prime ministers below Harper were
either in power very briefly – such as Kim Campbell, John Turner and
Joe Clark – or were otherwise forgettable, such as R.B. Bennett and
Arthur Meighen. For historians, to be considered an important prime
minister, you must leave behind a significant government program or
legislative milestone – such as Lester B. Pearson when he created
Medicare and the Canada Pension Plan, or Brian Mulroney with free trade
and the acid rain treaty.
“When I think of the Harper government, what would be a lasting
implication?” asks Dimitry Anastakis, a historian at Trent University.
“There are a lot of takeaways the government has done in terms of
diminishing the capacity of government. I suppose that is the legacy. I
don’t think it’s a positive legacy — I think it is a very negative
legacy.”
Even conservatives can’t point to major achievements. Tom Flanagan
says with the exception of some criminal justice reforms, Harper has not
delivered on social conservative issues, such as abortion or gay
marriage, and didn’t end things like corporate subsidies. Flanagan does
point to lowering the tax burden on Canadians as Harper’s biggest
accomplishment – in particular the childcare benefit and tax cuts to
parents with children. “I felt [the previous tax system] was unfair to
parents raising a family,” he says.
On the childcare front, Harper scrapped plans for a national daycare
program that Paul Martin had promised. And the childcare benefit and tax
cuts don’t come close to covering the cost of daycare for an average
parent.
But is Harper the worst prime minister in Canadian history?
Investigative journalist Michael Harris, author of Party of One,
the bestseller about Harper’s tenure, believes so. “There is something
very Stalinesque about Harper,” remarks Harris. “My bottom line on this
guy is, he hates democracy. He doesn’t care about truth and cares only
about the perception of what benefits him. In that way he’s way worse
[than his predecessors].”
Naturally, assessing Harper’s legacy depends on your own politics:
conservatives will view him more kindly than liberals and leftists.
Moreover, Harper does not rule in the same environment as prime
ministers of the past. “I say to people who say this is the worst ever –
really? Ask any visible minority, aboriginal or woman how the
government treated them before 1975,” says Duff Conacher, founder of
Democracy Watch, an Ottawa-based civil liberties organization.
Still, given his longevity in power, and in regards to the
fundamental things people grade a government on – such as the economy,
democratic practices, the environment, corruption, foreign policy,
culture, civil liberties – Harper’s record might very well place him as
the worst prime minister in Canadian history.
His democratic record
When Canadian Press reporter Dene Moore asked to interview Fisheries
and Oceans Canada scientist Max Bothwell last year about a particular
type of algae he studies, her request was denied. Out of curiosity, CP
made an access to information request to find out why – and discovered
that Moore’s simple request had generated 110 pages of emails between 16
different government communications staffers.
Why such agitation? The Environmental Law Association at the
University of Victoria speculates that certain subjects are red-flagged
within the government because they might be to issues important to the
oil industry. And algae growth is linked to climate change.
If there is one area in which Harper is particularly vulnerable, it’s
the charge that he runs one of the most undemocratic regimes in
Canadian history – and has undermined and abused democratic institutions
and procedures at every turn. In fact, he is the only Canadian prime
minister to be found in contempt of Parliament, which occurred in 2011
after his government refused to release costs on certain programs to
opposition MPs. Photo of Prime Minister Stephen Harper by Danny Kresnyak A more recent example is Bill C-51,
the government’s anti-terrorism legislation, which critics say will
criminalize free speech and allow government agencies to widely share
personal information without any regard to privacy, while giving CSIS,
RCMP and CSEC freer range to spy on whomever they choose. The law also
allows these agencies to hold people up to a week in “preventative
detention."
Last year, Democracy Watch released its annual report card on the
government’s performance, giving it an “F” on accountability and
democratic reform. “The secret unethical lobbying, excessive secrecy,
conflict of interest, and donations scandals in 2013, and the broken
promises… make it clear that another Accountability Act is needed to
close dozens of loopholes and clean up the federal government,” Conacher
said at the time.
After Harper became prime minister, he introduced the Federal
Accountability Act (FAA). But Conacher says that only 29 of the act’s 60
promised reforms were put in place (seven were then rolled back). “The
biggest thing they did, which was really bad, was to break 31 other
promises,” he says.
Conacher notes that Harper did make some positive changes, such as
creating the parliamentary budget office, improving oversight of
lobbyists, lowering the amount that corporations can contribute to
federal parties, extending the Access to Information Act to more
government agencies, and making it harder for parliamentary staff to get
public service jobs.
Yet these have been offset by a laundry list of undemocratic actions, which include:
Proroguing Parliament four times, shutting it down for a total of 181 days.
In 2008, Harper prorogued Parliament after opposition parties
threatened to bring down his minority government. He did it twice more
in 2009 when Harper claimed he wanted to keep Parliament in recess
during the Winter Olympics (while opposition members felt it was to
avoid investigations into the Afghan detainee affair)— and the fourth
time was in 2013 after the opposition said he was avoiding questions
over the Senate spending scandal.
Omnibus bills. Starting in 2010, Harper tabled a
bill with 883 pages that included changes to Canada Post and
environmental assessments. Since then, Harper has passed 10 more omnibus
bills to circumvent debate in parliament, often making sweeping changes
to laws and regulations. “All have been an abuse of process and shown
contempt for Parliament by subverting its role,” editorialized The Globe and Mail
last fall. “Major changes to policy and law that should have been
examined by MPs have been pushed through with almost no debate,
sometimes with disastrous results.”
One bill attempted to appoint Justice Marc Nadon to the Supreme
Court, although he was not eligible. In 2012, one of the omnibus bills,
C-38, completely gutted Canada’s environmental laws, cut $36-billion
from health care funding, weakened Canada’s food inspectors through job
cuts, and made it harder to qualify for EI benefits.
Robocalling during the 2011 election. Michael Harris, in his book Party of One,
calls it “Canada’s worst election scandal.” Just prior to election day,
some voters across Canada received recorded calls that either told them
to go to the wrong polling station, or were of a harassing nature,
purportedly made by opposition parties. The targeted voters didn't
support the Conservatives. Investigations revealed the involvement of
RackNine Inc., a political consulting firm the Conservatives hired, and
Michael Sona, a low-level Conservative party staffer who was sentenced
last year to nine months in prison for his role. Two judges found that
it was likely other senior Tories were involved.
Fair Elections Act. Last year the Harper government
overhauled Canada’s election laws to deal with electoral fraud. But its
critics soon labeled it the “Unfair Elections Act” because it weakened
the power of Elections Canada, effectively muzzling the chief electoral
officer from communicating with the public and MPs about investigations,
and cut off the agency’s investigations arm, while polling supervisors
were now to be appointed by the incumbent party’s candidate or party.
(Elections Canada used to appoint them.)
Gagging scientists from speaking freely about their research.
Numerous scientists have been prevented from speaking to the media,
especially those researching the environment. The government has also
been accused of sending “minders” when some scientists have attended
international conferences, along with speaking points, to ensure they
stay on message.
In 2013, the Professional Institute of the Public Service of Canada
(PIPSC), which represents 20,000 federal scientists, found that hundreds
of their members said they had been asked to exclude or alter technical
information in government documents for non-scientific reasons, and
thousands said they had been prevented from responding to the media or
the public.
Spying on environmental and aboriginal activists.
Jeffrey Monaghan, a criminologist at Carleton University, has obtained
documents from CSIS and RCMP through access to information laws that
reveal how these agencies are spying on the environmental movement,
especially those opposed to pipelines or who participate in National
Energy Board (NEB) hearings.
These groups include Idle No More, Leadnow, ForestEthics Advocacy,
the Council of Canadians, the Dogwood Initiative, EcoSociety, and the
Sierra Club of British Columbia. The documents show how information on
various groups is shared among the intelligence agencies and the NEB.
They also revealed that twice a year, at the CSIS headquarters in
Ottawa, top-ranking members of the RCMP, CSIS and the CSEC meet with oil
industry representatives to brief them on the “threat” from
environmental and aboriginal groups.
Photo
of Grand Chief Stewart Phillip and Tsleil-Waututh elder Amy George
protesting the Kinder Morgan pipeline expansion by Mychaylo Prystupa
Auditing environmental and civil society groups.
In the 2012 budget, the government announced it was going to earmark
$8-million so that the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) could begin auditing
selected charities. Seven environmental groups were soon targeted.
This sum has since been increased to $13-million a year and expanded
to anti-poverty, foreign aid and human rights groups, such as Amnesty
International, as well as the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives
and United Church of Canada. Last fall, the Broadbent Institute issued a
report that said these audits were politically motivated – because no
conservative think tanks or groups had been targeted.
Taxpayer-funded political ads. This spring, Finance Canada is planning to spend $13.5-million on ads to boast about the government’s budget. The Toronto Star estimates
that $500-million has been spent by the Harper government since 2009
promoting its programs – $75-million in 2014 alone. Finance spent
$7.5-million on Economic Action Plan ads, Employment and Social
Development spent $7-million on a skills initiative campaign, and the
CRA spent $6-million on ads about new tax measures. Queen’s University
political science professor Jonathan Rose told The Globe and Mail recently: “What’s so egregious is the blatant way that they’re priming the electorate before an election.”
For many political observers, one of the most alarming changes Harper
has ushered in is not even legislative: it’s the way in which political
discourse is conducted. “They have a clear policy of dishonest spin on
almost everything,” says Conacher. “They’ve done that far more than any
other government in the last 25 years, which is to lie and stick to the
lie.”
A recent example happened last week when the Prime Minister’s Office
posted two videos online of Harper visiting special forces soldiers in
Iraq, in violation of security protocols. When this was raised, the PMO
first claimed the protocols had not been breached, and then claimed
defence officials had vetted them, before they issued an evasive
apology.
Michael Harris agrees with Conacher, saying “(Harper) is a person who
does not believe in the truth… For the prime minister of a country
where he’s setting the entire agenda and putting the signature across a
whole government and where words don’t mean much, we are in a lot of
trouble… He is the first prime minister who is a marketer, an aluminum
siding salesman. He is not a truth teller.”
His economic record
This past March, in an article headlined “Why Canada’s economy is
headed off the cliff,” Yale University economics lecturer Vikram
Mansharamani argued that Canada is among the most vulnerable large
economies in the world. With a high level of consumer debt
($1.82-trillion) that now exceeds GDP ($1.6-trillion), combined with
rising housing prices and dropping oil prices, he concluded: “It seems
our Crazy Canadian Coyote has run off the cliff.”
Stephen Harper has based much of his credibility on being a capable
steward of the economy – supposedly the strongest in the G7 – and will
likely be using this as a plank in his re-election campaign.
But what’s the real story?
“Five years of recovery and this economy is the weakest we’ve ever
seen,” says Armine Yalnizyan, senior economist at the Canadian Centre
for Policy Alternatives. “I think the majority of Canadians are worse
off than they were in 2006 – they have not seen wage gains keep up with
cost increases.
And I think most people who have children are worried
about their kids’ future.”
Tonya Richardson, 45, would agree. A vivacious single mother of a
10-year-old boy who lives in Toronto, Richardson lost her job as a job
recruitment consultant this past February. Richardson says until 2008
she was earning up to $60,000 a year, but then lost about $15,000 of her
income after the economy tanked and commissions declined. Now she’s
receiving a total of $2,000 a month on EI. “It’s a tough (job) market
out there,” she says. “It’s a really frustrating time – no one is
getting call backs. Not having child support, and it’s getting to month
three [without work], the stress levels are high.”
When he was elected in 2006, Harper inherited a booming
economy. With commodity prices surging, the economy was growing at three
per cent per year, with an unemployment rate of 6.6 per cent. The
government was running a surplus of more than $13-billion, and net debt
was $492-billion (and falling).
Fast forward to now and the unemployment rate is 6.8 per cent and
climbing, with job growth anemic: only 121,000 jobs were created last
year (three-quarters of which were temporary), which did not keep pace
with population growth of 308,000. The commodities boom has cooled, in
particular with oil prices plunging.
Harper has run deficits since 2008, and the federal debt is now $615-billion and rising.
But that’s not the alarming thing. In the five years prior to 2006,
Canada’s manufacturing industries lost 200,000 jobs. After Harper was
elected, another 400,000 manufacturing jobs vanished, with manufacturing
as a share of the economy dropping from 16 per cent in 2004 down to 12
per cent last year. The high-tech manufacturing sector is in terrible
shape, having shrunk to 1.3 per cent of GDP, making it one of the
smallest in the developed world.
The loss of manufacturing is germane to how Canada’s economy is
changing – and not for the better. In 2000, Canada had a well-rounded
economy, with value-added products accounting for over 60 per cent of
exports. But according to Jim Stanford, chief economist of the Unifor
trade union, free trade and a strong dollar decimated Canada’s
manufacturing base. Thus, notes Stanford, by 2010 value-added products
had fallen by one-third, and “unprocessed or barely-processed resource
products once again accounted for the lion’s share of total exports.” In
other words, Canada was returning to becoming a country of “hewers of
wood and drawers of water” – digging up oil and minerals for other
countries to turn into products. Oil sands aerial photo by Andrew S. Wright Harper, as it turns out, was the worst person
to become prime minister given these circumstances. As a follower of the
Austrian economist Friedrich Hayek, Harper’s approach is not to
interfere in the economy, except for cutting taxes. Thus, he deducted
two points from the GST, and slashed corporate taxes from 22 per cent
down to 15 per cent, and cut personal taxes.
But this made the government ill-equipped for the 2008-’09 recession:
one estimate says tax cuts cost the treasury roughly $34-billion per
year. Surpluses quickly vanished just when he needed to prime the
economic pump. And as the recession deepened, he was forced to borrow
money – thereby generating greater debt – to prevent a more severe
downturn.
As manufacturing declined, Harper did not step in to rescue this
sector. Instead, he placed his bets on the growing resource extraction
industries, in particular oil.
Did this make the Canadian economy stronger or weaker?
By focusing on commodities, Canada was susceptible to a bust in
commodity prices – in particular when oil prices tumbled last year. So,
as the American economy is now taking off, the Canadian economy is
sinking. “We entered the [2008-09 economic] crisis with the
eighth-largest economy in the world,” says Yalnizyan. “We are now
ranking 11th and sliding down that greasy pole as other countries move
it up as they capture production – because they have lower costs and
equally high investment in skills.”
“We have slipped towards the status we held in the global economy
about 100 years ago,” she continues, “but that is not actually enough to
stay in the top tier of nations.”
Moreover, Yalnizyan says Harper has not developed an alternative
renewable energy sector, the way China is doing. “We are not investing
in that – instead we are subsidizing extraction and fighting over
pipelines… We should be at front end of that [renewables] parade and we
are not doing it.”
How has the average Canadian household fared under Harper? People
like Tonya Richardson are falling out of the middle class: she pays
almost $1,300 a month in rent, leaving her only $700 to cover food for
her and her boy and other living expenses. “I have been living hand to
mouth to raise my son,” she says.
In fact, under Harper, median income (after taxes) rose for the first
two years after he was elected, and then plateaued (2011 is the last
year statistics are available). EKOS Research surveys show that since
the start of the 2000s, Canadians identifying themselves as middle class
have declined from 70 per cent to about 60 per cent of adults. In a
2014 survey by Yconic, a Canadian company that conducts research panels
with millennials, 43 per cent of those between 30 and 33 said they were
still relying on financial help from family.
Meanwhile, the level of consumer debt has shot up from just under
$1-trillion in 2006 to $1.82-trillion today, which means that for every
$100 in disposable income, Canadian households owe $163 in debt (some
economists say this is offset by the growth in Canadians’ net value in
savings and assets and is not overly alarming).
While the middle class struggles, the rich have grown richer. According to figures derived from Canadian Business magazine,
by 2012 the 86 wealthiest Canadian-resident individuals (and families)
held the same amount of wealth as the poorest 11.4 million Canadians
combined — or almost one-third of the population. The average wage in
Canada increased by six per cent between 1998 and 2012 while the average
compensation of Canada’s highest paid 100 CEOs increased by 73 per cent
during that same period.
Moreover, Harper’s corporate tax cuts did nothing to strengthen
private sector investment, which has been falling since 2010, while
corporate cash or “dead money” has been climbing.
Stanford sums up Harper’s legacy this way: “Our R&D performance
is among the worst of any industrialized country. So is our productivity
growth. This is where the Harper vision is really vulnerable. They talk
about free markets and business efficiency but the average productivity
growth since Harper has come on is 0.5 per cent per year, and that
would be the weakest productivity growth in postwar history… I would
conclude quite strongly that Canada’s economic performance on a range of
measures – job creation, income productivity, business investment,
trade performance and even fiscal affairs – has been the worst of any
government [since the Second World War].”
His environmental record
Back in 2002, when Harper was leader of the Canadian Alliance, he
sent a letter to supporters saying “We’re gearing up for the biggest
struggle our party has faced since you entrusted me with the leadership.
I’m talking about the ‘Battle of Kyoto’ — our campaign to block the
job-killing, economy-destroying Kyoto Accord.” Soon after he won his
majority in 2011, Harper pulled Canada out of Kyoto, the first signatory
to do so. Photo of Prime Minister Stephen Harper at the Vancouver Board of Trade and climate protesters by David P. Ball
Despite that 13 of the hottest years on record
have occurred since 2000 (and 2014 was the very hottest) Harper has
fought every effort to impose climate change measures.
Thus, Germanwatch and Climate Action Network Europe — which produce
an annual report card on climate change performance — put Canada 58th
out of 61 countries in regards to its efforts to combat global warming,
above only Saudi Arabia, Kazakhstan and Australia. In 2013, these
organizations said Canada “shows no intention of moving forward with
climate policy and therefore remains the worst performer of all
industrialized countries.” Last fall, the liberal American magazine The New Republic called Harper and his Australian counterpart Tony Abbot “earth’s worst climate villains.”
During Harper’s tenure, emissions of greenhouse gases peaked in 2007
at 761 megatonnes, then fell during the recession, but has been steadily
rising again, although still below 2007 levels. According to
Environment Canada, while Canada accounted for 2.1 per cent of global
CO2 emissions in 2005, it fell to 1.8 per cent in 2010 and is expected
to fall to 1.6 per cent by 2020.
So why is Canada being cast as an environmental villain?
It’s largely because Harper refuses to sign any binding agreement
that would force Canada to meet climate change targets and significantly
cut greenhouse emissions. Last December, Environment Canada said that
by 2020, Canada would be producing 727 megatonnes of CO2, which is far
higher than the 611 megatonnes Harper targeted at the Copenhagen climate
change summit in 2009. The report said that emissions from the oil and
gas sector would grow by 45 megatonnes between 2005 and 2020, nearly
offsetting the 50 megatonne reduction expected in the electricity
sector.
The reasons for Harper’s inaction are no surprise. For one, it’s long
been suspected he doesn’t believe climate change poses a threat. But
then there’s a purely political calculation: his party enjoys broad
support in Alberta, and his economic agenda has been focused on
developing the oil sands. “If you look at Canada’s greenhouse gas
emissions, Alberta emits more gas than Ontario and Quebec combined
[although] 60 per cent of Canadians live in Ontario and Quebec,” says
Erin Flanagan, an oil sands analyst with the Pembina Institute, an
energy think tank.
The Harper government has also fought to get Keystone XL built, along
with other pipelines accessing the tar sands. Because pipelines reduce
the cost of transporting bitumen, they make the tar sands more viable
for the oil industry, but also make it more likely that up to 240
billion metric tons of carbon could be released into the atmosphere.
In 2012, the government launched an unprecedented assault on Canada’s
environmental laws when it introduced Bill C-38, mentioned above – an
omnibus bill that put a halt to automatic environmental assessments of
projects under the federal government’s purview.
All told, the Fisheries Act, Navigable Waters Protection Act and
Canadian Environmental Assessment Act were either repealed or simply
gutted, while the NEB was neutered.
“So you can go through all the legislation that was changed… there’s a
direct link to the long-standing requests of the oil industry to remove
these environmental barriers to rapid resource development,” says Tim
Gray, executive director of Environmental Defence, a Toronto-based
environmental group.
Indeed, the consequences were summed up by Green Party Leader
Elizabeth May, who noted: “In Bill C-38, Stephen Harper canceled and
gutted environmental laws brought in by Brian Mulroney. He’s now moved
on to destroy environmental laws brought in by Sir John A. MacDonald.”
Overall, Harper’s environmental record has isolated Canada on the
world stage. Last September, he refused to fly to a UN-sponsored climate
change summit in New York attended by 120 world leaders, sending his
environment minister instead.
“Overall, it’s worse off. Definitely worse off. We have a weaker
democracy. We have a weaker social justice system. We have compromised
the environment for many decades to come. So, Harper's is one of the
worst governments we've ever had.”
It's 7:17 AM on the morning of
June 30, 1908, the exact moment when Nikoli Tesla is testing his "Death
Ray" by aiming his beam towards the Arctic Cirle where he hopes Admiral
Peary will see a visual display in the sky.
In the small Siberian village, herders of Raindeer are awoken by a huge
ball of light, followed by an enormous explosion. Seismic vibrations
were recorded by sensitive instruments as much as 1000 km (600 mi) away.
At 500 km (300 mi), observers reported "deafening bangs" and a fiery
cloud on the horizon. About 170 km (110 mi) from the explosion, the
object was seen in the cloudless, daytime sky as a brilliant, sunlike
fireball; thunderous noises were heard. At distances around 60 km,
people were thrown to the ground or even knocked unconscious; windows
were broken and crockery knocked off shelves. Probably the closest
observers were some reindeer herders asleep in their tents in several
camps about 30 km (20 mi) from the site. They were blown into the air
and knocked unconscious; one man was blown into a tree and later died.
"Everything around was shrouded in smoke and fog from the burning fallen
trees."
Some eye-witness reports
Irkutsk newspaper Sibir:
'in the village of Nizhne-Karelinsk in the northwest high above the
horizon, the peasants saw a body shining very brightly -(too bright for
the naked eye) with a bluish white light. It moved vertically down-wards
for about ten minutes. The body was in the form of a 'pipe' (i.e.
cylindrical). The sky was cloudless, except that low down on the horizon
in the direction in which this glowing body was observed, a small dark
cloud was noticed. It was hot and dry and when the shining body
approached the ground it seemed to be pulverized and in its place a huge
cloud of black smoke was formed and a loud crash, not like thunder, but
as if from the fall of large stones, or from gunfire, was heard. All
the buildings shook and at the same time, a forked tongue of flame broke
through the cloud. The old women wept, everyone thought that the end of
the world was approaching.'
400 Kilometers Southeast of Ground Zero
Witnesses in the town of Kirensk and nearby towns at the same distance
recollected the fireball flashing across the sky in the following terms:
"A ball of fire...coming down obliquely. A few minutes later [we heard]
separate deafening crash like peals of thunder...followed by eight loud
bangs like gunshots."
"A ball of fire appeared in the sky... As it approached the ground, it took on a flattened shape..."
"A flying star with a fiery tail; its tail disappeared into the air."
60 Miles from Ground Zero
"I was sitting on the porch of the house at the trading station, looking
north. Suddenly in the north...the sky was split in two, and high above
the forest the whole northern part of the sky appeared covered with
fire. I felt a great heat, as if my shirt had caught fire... At that
moment there was a bang in the sky, and a mighty crash... I was thrown
twenty feet from the porch and lost consciousness for a moment.... The
crash was followed by a noise like stones falling from the sky, or guns
firing. The earth trembled.... At the moment when the sky opened, a hot
wind, as if from a cannon, blew past the huts from the north. It damaged
the onion plants. Later, we found that many panes in the windows had
been blown out and the iron hasp in the barn door had been broken."
"I saw the sky in the north open to the ground and fire poured out. The
fire was brighter than the sun. We were terrified, but the sky closed
again and immediately afterward, bangs like gunshots were heard. We
thought stones were falling... I ran with my head down and covered,
because I was afraid stones may fall on it."
15 Kilometers from Ground Zero
"Early in the morning when everyone was asleep in the tent, it was blown
up in the air along with its occupants. Some lost consciousness. When
they regained consciousness, they heard a great deal of noise and saw
the forest burning around them, much of it devastated."
"The ground shook and incredibly prolonged roaring was heard. Everything
round about was shrouded in smoke and fog from burning, falling trees.
Eventually the noise died away and the wind dropped, but the forest went
on burning. Many reindeer rushed away and were lost."
Islam vs Christianity Infographic Source: https://www.jashow.org/articles/islam/christianity-islam-compared/islam-vs-christianity-infographic/?inf_contact_key=ee2c49b752535c81ac0908e39ccbebd553e434a119bfb6ab9ff5c032037c8e30
The Curious Kecksburg
'UFO' Crash Continues
To Intrigue By David Templeton
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
9-9-98
Since the uncertain events of Dec. 9,
1965, debate has raged, friendships have soured, rumors have waxed, theories
have arisen and Internet stories have proliferated over what crash-landed
that day in the rural village of Kecksburg, Westmoreland County.
The military insisted it was a meteorite
that was never recovered.
UFO skeptics have held that, if not an
outright hoax, it was surely something as explainable as the Soviet Venus
probe, Kosmos 96, or an experimental American spacecraft that went flip-flop
into Kecksburg's midsection only to be recovered by a quick and secretive
military.
But UFO researchers, who say the Kecksburg
incident is second only to the one at Roswell, N.M., in terms of drama
and potential, have suggested with as much imagination as fact that it
was alien visitors who chose Kecksburg as their Sea of Tranquility.
All of which has transformed the event
that happened 33 years ago into one of America's most intriguing UFO mysteries.
(Image: Sketch by Charles Hanna represents
an object that landed in Kecksburg on Dec. 9, 1965, thought by some to
be a UFO. (Matt Freed, Post-Gazette)¿
The Kecksburg incident has served as
fodder for episodes of "Unsolved Mysteries" and "Sightings"
television broadcasts. The mock-up spacecraft built for the "Unsolved
Mysteries" broadcast now sits atop the Kecksburg fire hall as the
only lasting sign of the village's controversial claim to fame.
Now, Greensburg UFO researcher Stan Gordon,
who has studied the Kecksburg crash since the day it happened, has produced
a 92-minute documentary titled, "Kecksburg: The Untold Story,"
that provides eyewitness accounts and claims that surely will bolster debate.
As the cover says, "New Mexico has
Roswell, but in Pennsylvania, it was Kecksburg,"
The most persistent Kecksburg researcher,
Gordon has long kept an open mind as to what may have landed, but always
has been intrigued by possibilities of an extraterrestrial visit. He now
adds to the literature, legend and litany with his video that provides
not only overwhelming evidence that something acorn-shaped landed in Kecksburg's
lap that day, but also new accounts that what landed was extraterrestrial.
Written and narrated by Gordon, 48, the
video provides numerous eyewitness testimonials from people who saw the
fireball cruise at rather low speeds and altitudes across the southwestern
Pennsylvania sky, maneuver, complete some turns and finally put down in
Kecksburg's woods, about 7 miles southeast of Greensburg.
Others who went rummaging through the
woods that early evening say they saw an acorn-shaped spacecraft half buried
in a gully. Many others, including news reporters, saw Kecksburg crawling
with military personnel from the Air Force, Army and NASA that evening,
while others saw a Volkswagen Beetle-sized craft removed under a tarpaulin
on the back of a military flatbed truck. Still others say they saw it being
hauled to Wright-Patterson Air Force Base in Dayton, Ohio.
Swirling with eerie music, subplots,
mysteries and theories, the video builds to a well-orchestrated climax
of two men claiming evidence that it was an extraterrestrial spacecraft.
One even claims to have seen what appeared to be a deceased, lizard-skinned
creature partially covered by a sheet inside a Wright-Patterson Air Force
Base hangar.
Gordon comes to no conclusions, except
that something definitely landed in Kecksburg at 4:45 p.m. on that day.
While entertaining the possibility that the craft was American or Soviet,
Gordon provides reasons why those explanations are lacking. He leaves the
viewer with the definite sense that his research points squarely at something
more profound.
"It's an intriguing story,"
he said in a recent interview. "It's been almost 33 years and we still
don't have an answer. A lot of key witnesses have passed away, are up in
age, or not in the best of health. This was the best way to have them tell
their story themselves about what they experienced."
His video provides detailed history of
the Kecksburg incident along with a long string of witnesses who provide
theories, surprises and intrigue, yet leave the viewer yearning for some
conclusion. With that in mind, Gordon asks viewers to petition members
of Congress to schedule hearings to collect testimony and help solve the
lingering mystery.
For years, debate has been escalating.
A 1991 article in The Pittsburgh Press
described generally what happened, based on various witnesses accounts
that are included in greater detail in Gordon's video.
Dec. 9, 1965, was a dreary day in Westmoreland
County - that is, until what was described as a roundish fireball appeared.
It reportedly seared the gray sky at low altitude with a jet trail, then
made S-turns and what appeared to be a controlled landing through the treetops
into Kecksburg's woods.
The fireball was seen across the northeastern
United States and was the subject of numerous newscasts that day.
Local residents headed toward the landing
site. James Romansky and others trailed the object into the woods by observing
the arc-wielding flames and bluish sparklers evident through the trees
after the landing.
The object was 12 feet long and 6 to
7 feet in diameter, and shaped like an acorn. It had a ring around the
base, just like an acorn, that bore what Romansky described as backward
letters, like a backward J or K. Some have described the lettering as resembling
Egyptian hieroglyphics - lines, stars, circles and shapes. The craft had
no doors or windows. The metal was seamless, with a dent, but bearing no
rivets or welds.
The local men soon were chased away by
U.S. military officials who announced that the landing site was off-limits
to all civilians.
As the writer of the 1991 article, this
reporter explored whether the spacecraft could have been the Soviet Venus
probe known as Kosmos 96. The U.S. Space Command reported that Kosmos 96
crash-landed in Canada shortly after 3 a.m. - more than 12 hours before
the Kecksburg crash at 4:45 p.m.
To this day, Kosmos 96 cannot be discounted
as a possibility.
Kosmos 96 was shaped like an acorn and
may have had the ability to maneuver to land on Venus. As a Venus probe,
it also was equipped with state-of-the-art heat shield technology that
could have allowed the craft to survive the long, heated ride through Earth's
atmosphere before landing in Kecksburg.
But there are discrepancies. Eyewitnesses,
including Romansky, insist the writing on the girth was not Russian. Others
claim that while the right shape, it was not the right size, and did not
bear the seams and rivets that characterized Soviet and U.S. spacecraft
of that era.
In 1991, I obtained the ordinants from
the Goddard Space Center for the flight of Kosmos 96. I had James Oberg,
an expert on Soviet spacecraft who also is a UFO skeptic, review the ordinants
to see if it could have been Kosmos 96. Oberg concluded that, based on
the ordinants provided by the Goddard Space Center, it could not be Kosmos
96 - a point that, to Oberg's dismay, buoyed UFO advocates and has continued
to be a hot topic on the Internet.
But Oberg amended his theories in an
article published in September 1993 on the OMNI service on America On Line.
There, he suggested that the Kosmos 96 theory could account for U.S. Space
Command's conclusions that it landed in Canada and also in Kecksburg.
Oberg says the failed Soviet probe "whose
booster had blown up in parking orbit, would have been a wonderful UFO."
Oberg acknowledges that the ordinants,
which have been reviewed by a leading amateur satellite watcher who didn't
want his name revealed, seemed to confirm the official Air Force account
that Kosmos 96 crashed in Canada more than 12 hours earlier than the Kecksburg
crash. But Oberg checked the data further. The released tracking data,
he said, couldn't be positively identified with specific pieces of the
failed probe.
"It could have been jettisoned rocket
stage of a large piece of space junk," he wrote. "The probe itself
could have headed off toward Kecksburg."
Oberg proceeds to explain why the U.S.
military would lie, or at least decide not to divulge everything it knew
about the Kecksburg crash.
"In the 1960s, U.S. military intelligence
agencies interested in enemy technology were eagerly collecting all the
Soviet missile and space debris they could find. International law required
that debris be returned to the country of origin. But hardware from Kosmos
96, with its special missile-warhead shielding, would have been too valuable
to give back."
After all, he concluded, what better
camouflage than to let people think the fallen object was not a Soviet
probe, but a flying saucer?
"The Russians would never suspect,
and the Air Force laboratories could examine the specimen at leisure. And
if suspicion lingered, UFO buffs would be counted on to maintain the phony
cover story, protecting the real truth."
For that reason, Oberg concluded, the
Kecksburg scenario produced "delicious irony."
"A famous UFO case may actually
involve a real U.S. government cover-up, but UFO buffs are on the wrong
side. Instead of exposing the truth, they may be unwitting pawns in deception."
The other unexplored avenue to solve
the Kecksburg mystery was to approach Soviet, now Russian, authorities
to provide information on what truly happened to Kosmos 96. But in 1991,
the Soviet Embassy would only speculate that anything that crash-landed
in American turf was probably American technology that the U.S. was too
embarrassed to acknowledge.
That's similar to the response that Gordon
got from the Russian government when he posed the same question.
In May, during an interview of a Russian
Cosmonaut Viktor P. Savinykh, who now serves as rector of Moscow State
University of Geodesy and Cartography, I took the opportunity through an
interpreter to ask him whether he could help solve the Kecksburg mystery.
He, too, suggested rather emphatically, and with some laughter, that whatever
plunged into Kecksburg surely was some faulty American technology.
But extraterrestrial claims cannot be
entertained until the Kosmos 96 theory is put to rest.
In 1962, the United States and Soviet
Union forged a gentleman's agreement that any spacecraft that landed within
the other's borders would be returned. However, the United States had fast-acting
military units that traveled the globe at moment's notice to recover American
and Soviet space hardware wherever it fell.
The Kecksburg crash occurred in the middle
of the Cold War and the space race, and America was especially interested
in heat-shield technology. So, if Kosmos 96 had landed in Kecksburg, there's
no doubt that the U.S. military would have been interested in finding it.
Gordon's video provides plenty of evidence
that the military would not have responded so quickly, and declared what
could only be described as martial law in Kecksburg, if it was responding
only to a meteorite.
Whether you adhere to theories of a hoax,
Kosmos 96 or extraterrestrial spacecraft, Gordon's video provides a thorough
account of the crash-landing, and the many explanations of what happened.
Submitted by Tyler Durden on 09/30/2015 18:41 -0400
When RealtyTrac released its latest home sales report,
"which shows single family home and condo sales through August were on
pace for an eight-year high nationwide and in 110 out of 204" it was
something else that caught our eye. According to RealtyTrac president
Daren Blomquist, "the continued strength in sales volume across a wide
spectrum of markets in August indicates that shockwaves from recent
global stock market instability have not weakened the housing recovery
and in fact there is evidence that the instability has fueled more
demand for U.S. real estate."
Which was to be expected: as we have said for the past 4 years, one
of the three pillars supporting US housing, or at least the very high
end, is the money laundering of offshore hot money in the US, where
courtesy of the NAR's exemption from anti-money laundering provisions,
wealthy foreigners can park any amount of cash in US housing without any
questions asked. In August this was particularly acute because as
Blomquist adds, "cash sales share was more pronounced in markets that
have traditionally been magnets for foreign cash buyers, including
Boston, Las Vegas, San Francisco, Seattle and New York.”
And here was the stunner in question: "We are seeing more
globalization as Southern California has become a destination for
international buyers," said Mark Hughes, chief operating officer with
First Team Real Estate, covering the Southern California market. "Eighty percent of new construction in Irvine last year was sold to Chinese buyers. International buyers are driving home prices up and sometimes out of reach for many local residents."
You read that right, a whopping 80% of all new housing in Irvine was bought by Chinese.
Which prompted some follow up reading. This is what we found:
California is the most popular U.S. destination for Chinese real
estate buyers, according to Juwai.com, a Hong Kong-based property search
engine.
Chinese bought 32% of homes sold to foreign buyers in California, double the share sold to Canadians, according to an April 2014 survey by the California Association of Realtors. About 70 percent of international buyers pay cash, the survey showed.
Buyers from Greater China, including people from Hong Kong and
Taiwan, spent $22 billion on U.S. homes in the first quarter of 2014, up 72 percent from the same period in 2013 and
more than any other nationality, the National Association of Realtors
said yesterday in its annual report on foreign home purchases. That’s 24 cents of every dollar spent by international homebuyers, according to the survey of 3,547 real estate agents.
"A lot of people are trying to hedge against a generally bearish
outlook for the Chinese economy,” Hanemann said in a telephone
interview. “Buying real estate overseas has been in the past limited to a
relatively small group of wealthy individuals and sometimes government
officials. But it’s become a much bigger trend, involving affluent
middle-class people."
Affluent being the key word: Chinese buyers paid a median of $523,148 per transaction,
compared with a U.S. median price of $199,575 for existing-home sales.
While Canadians bought more houses than the Chinese, they spent less -- a
median of $212,500 per residence, for a total of $13.8 billion.
To be sure, the Chinese influx was felt particularly during 2014 when
the first reverberations of the burst Chinese housing bubble were felt,
and forced many to look to the US for parking capital for safety: "The
uncertainties in China’s domestic market are contributing to a higher
rate of growth in Chinese interest in U.S. property,” Andrew Taylor,
co-chief executive officer of Juwai.com, said in an e-mail. “That
interest began accelerating in the second quarter of 2014, in part
because of China’s property slowdown."
It remains to be seen if the recent modest uptick in Chinese housing
transactions, if not prices, will lead to a capital reallocation by
Chinese buyers out of California and back into China. But in the
meantime, Chinese buyers have made numerous domestic housing markets
inaccessible to average Amercians:
Buyers from China are driving up prices and fueling new construction
in Southern California areas such as Arcadia, a city of about 57,500
people with top-rated schools, a large Chinese immigrant community and
an array of Chinese restaurants and markets.
The median home price in Arcadia’s 91006 ZIP code was $1.28 million
in mid-2014, up 18.5 percent from a year earlier, according to research
firm DataQuick.
“About 90 percent of my buyers are from China,”
said Peggy Fong Chen, a broker with Re/Max Holdings Inc., who sold 80
homes in Arcadia last year. “They want new construction. They want two
levels. In China, it is considered a mansion if it has two levels.”
More than three out of four buyers pay cash, said
Chen, a native of Hong Kong who’s been selling real estate for 10 years.
At least 20 percent are absentee owners who don’t have long-term visas
yet. Many purchase houses for their children to attend high school or
college, she said.
Buyers from China and Asian-Americans purchased about 80
percent of the 47 houses sold at Tri Pointe Homes Inc.’s Arcadia at
Stonegate community in Irvine, about 40 miles southeast of Los Angeles, according to Tom Mitchell, president of the Irvine-based builder.
Almost half of the buyers paid cash for houses in the development,
at prices starting at $1.16 million, he said. The company has been
surprised by how word travels among overseas buyers. “A Chinese national
bought one of our houses at Arcadia in Irvine after reading about it on
a blog,” Tri Pointe CEO Doug Bauer said in a telephone interview. “It
was a Chinese blog. We couldn’t even read it.”
Which brings us to the key issue: uncontrolled Chinese money
laundering which is the primary reason for this capital exodus, and
billions in Chinese "hot money" bidding up luxury US real estate into
the stratosphere. We have discussed it extensively before, and here is bloomberg:
Some wealthy Chinese have come up with ways to
evade the yearly $50,000 per-person limit on taking money out of the
country so they can buy U.S. real estate, Yu said. Methods include
laundering money through Macau casinos and cooking the books of
import-export companies, he said.
“A lot of people over-invoice export proceeds, so they can park some money outside,” Ha
Jiming, chief investment strategist for Goldman Sachs Group Inc.’s
China investment management division, said at a Los Angeles conference
in April.
Putting a bottom line on the capital outflows, according to the NAR,
sales of U.S. houses to long-term foreign residents and non-resident
buyers accounted for about 7 percent of the $1.2 trillion of
existing-home transactions in just the first quarter of 2014.
So realistically, call it 10%, which means that mostly all cash
foreign buyers are responsible for about $500 billion in US real estate
all cash investment every year, of which anywhere between a third and a
half is Chinese.
And there is your massive Chinese capital outflows in a nutshell,
which incidentally is also the biggest threat facing China's economy now
that it has begun devaluing its currency and yet is desperate to avoid
the capital flight from its economy.
Which makes us wonder: if asked what presidents Xi and Obama really discussed
in private last week, a safe bet is it wasn't computer hacking, nor
artificial islands in the South China Sea, but how the US plans to curb
the outflow of hot Chinese money into US real estate.
Which is a problem for the US, because thanks to Chinese capital flows, it means half a trillion dollars in capital flow right into the US economy via real estate every year. Call
it 3% of GDP, roughly what the US growth rate should be. Xi is angry
that this capital is leaving his economy; Obama is delighted.
How will this very critical issue be resolved remains to be seen but
as we will note in a follow up post, China is already taking very
aggressive steps to finally limit and halt altogether the epic money
laundering that is sucking China's economy dry and is leading to such
dramatic outcomes as 80% of all buyers in a major US metro-area being
Chinese.